New Evidence Establishes that Narendra Modi was Directly Monitoring Tulsi Prajapati Fake Encounter

While researching the conspiracy behind Modi’s IT story, we also looked at the antecedents of Narendra Modi’s own website “”. We discovered that the registrant of Modi’s website is a gentleman named Parag Shah ( While researching Parag’s background, we found his LinkedIn profile:

Parag Shah's LinkedIn Profile
Parag Shah’s LinkedIn Profile

What caught our attention in Parag’s LinkedIn profile was his appointment as the “Officer on Special Duty (OSD)†to the Gujarat Chief Minister for the period 2003 to 2008 and another fact stated by him: “Associated with cyber cell of Anti-terrorist Squadâ€. This accidental finding lead us to the missing link of the Sohrabuddin-Tulsi Prajapati fake encounter!

Thereafter, we looked at the supplementary charge sheet filed by CBI in the Tulsi Prajapati case, specially where the CBI has elaborately dealt with the Call Data Records (CDR) of Amit Shah and Rajkumar Pandian, who were in constant touch with each other while monitoring the movements of Tulsi Prjapati between Udaipur (where he was jailed) and Ahmedabad (where he was being brought to attend a criminal case). We reproduce the extract of the CBI charge related to the month of December, 2006 (Tulsi Prajapati was murdered on 28th December early morning near Ambaji, Rajasthan-Gujarat border):

6.21. On 11.12.2006, an escort party from the Reserve Police Line, Udaipur, headed by Sub-Inspector Shyam Singh accompanied Tulsiram Prajapati and Mohd. Azam for Ahmedabad by train. On this date also, the mother and wife of Mohd. Azam had accompanied them to Ahmedabad. After reaching Ahmedabad on 12.12.2006, both Mohd. Azam and Tulsiram Prajapati were taken to the Sabarmati Jail, Ahmedabad, from there they were produced via video conferencing before the competent Court instead of being physically produced in the Court. The next date of hearing was fixed for 26.12.2006. The escort party while leaving for Udaipur in the night of 12.12.2006 at the Ahmedabad Railway Station made efforts in furtherance of the criminal conspiracy to separate the mother and wife of Mohd. Azam from Tulsiram Prajapati and his co-prisoner Mohd. Azam, but were prevented by the unexpected vociferous and vigorous protest by the mother and wife of Mohd. Azam that resulted in a large gathering of bystanders that deterred the police from succeeding in their objective of isolating Tulsiram Prajapati, a necessary preparatory stage for his murder in a planned fake encounter.

We are also reproducing in here the Call Data Record (CDR) from the CBI chargesheet for the relevant period:

Amit Shah Raj Kumar Pandian Calls
Amit Shah Raj Kumar Pandian Calls

The CDR fully establishes the contact between Rajkumar Pandian, the SP of Anti Terrorist Squad and the Home Minister Amit Shah in the murder of Tulsi Prajapati and both of them have been charge-sheeted as the main accused in the case. In fact, Rajkumar Pandian who was the SP of the ATS played a vital role in abduction of Sohrabuddin and Kauserbi and killing them both on 26th and 29th November, 2005 at Ahmedabad. In that case as well, both Amit Shah and Rajkumar Pandian are charged as accused.

As we had the CDRs of the accused officer Rajkumar Pandian, we searched within Pandian’s CDR for Parag Shah’s number after coming to know that he was appointed as the Officer on Special Duty for the Anti-Terrorist Squad. This appointment attains special significance since the Chief Minister’s office had declared their “No Tolerance” policy towards terrorism “and it was Mr Parag Shah as the OSD to CM who was to monitor the functions of ATS and report to the CM”. To our surprise we found a large number of phone calls between Pandian and Parag Shah inter-spaced with phone calls of Amit Shah and Pandian (Call Records reproduced at the bottom of the post). In light of the call records, it becomes abundantly clear that Mr Parag Shah was in constant touch with Rajkumar Pandyan IPS, the man who planned and executed the murder of Tulsiram Prajapati, and in turn Parag Shah was reporting to CM.

This piece of vital information read with the fact that Mr Parag Shah was working as the Officer on Special Duty for Narendra Modi, CM, it becomes obvious as day light that the CM was fully aware of the Tulsi fake encounter which was carried out entirely by the police officers working in Anti-Terrorist-Squad led by DIG Vanzara. In light of this irrefutable evidence, we can now interpret the statement made by D G Vanzara in his resignation letter recently tendered to the Government of Gujarat. His statement reads as under:

We, being field officers, have simply implemented the conscious policy of this government which was inspiring, guiding and monitoring our actions from the very close quarters

Would the CBI now care to explain to the nation why it has failed to investigate Parag Shah’s phone calls when they had the entire CDR with them? Was it to obfuscate the role of Narendra Modi?

Calling PartyNameCalled partyNameDurationDate/time
9427306077Pandian919427306014Parag10912/1/2006 13:01
9427306077Pandian919824010090Amit Shah1312/2/2006 8:14
919824010090Amit Shah9427306077Pandian1212/2/2006 9:36
919824010090Amit Shah9427306077Pandian5312/4/2006 19:10
919427306014Parag9427306077Pandian15812/5/2006 18:39
919824010090Amit Shah9427306077Pandian1212/5/2006 20:55
919824010090Amit Shah9427306077Pandian812/6/2006 8:23
9427306077Pandian919824010090Amit Shah2512/7/2006 10:21
919824010090Amit Shah9427306077Pandian3912/7/2006 17:12
919824010090Amit Shah9427306077Pandian2012/7/2006 18:05
9427306077Pandian919824010090Amit Shah1012/8/2006 21:32
919824010090Amit Shah9427306077Pandian7012/9/2006 11:59
919824010090Amit Shah9427306077Pandian3912/9/2006 14:03
9427306077Pandian919427306014Parag3612/10/2006 15:30
9427306077Pandian919824010090Amit Shah1812/11/2006 8:26
919824010090Amit Shah9427306077Pandian812/11/2006 11:57
919824010090Amit Shah9427306077Pandian612/11/2006 11:58
919824010090Amit Shah9427306077Pandian5912/11/2006 22:08
9427306077Pandian919427306014Parag3212/12/2006 11:54
919427306014Parag9427306077Pandian712/12/2006 16:52
919427306014Parag9427306077Pandian2512/12/2006 21:48
919427306014Parag9427306077Pandian3412/13/2006 15:56
919427306014Parag9427306077Pandian2412/14/2006 11:37
9427306077Pandian919427306014Parag17512/14/2006 13:35
919824010090Amit Shah9427306077Pandian3112/18/2006 10:16
919824010090Amit Shah9427306077Pandian2312/18/2006 12:05
919824010090Amit Shah9427306077Pandian8812/19/2006 22:07
919824010090Amit Shah9427306077Pandian8112/21/2006 18:01
9427306077Pandian919824010090Amit Shah2212/22/2006 18:46
9427306077Pandian919824010090Amit Shah712/23/2006 17:19
9427306077Pandian919824010090Amit Shah13312/23/2006 17:19
919824010090Amit Shah9427306077Pandian6612/24/2006 19:58
9427306077Pandian919824010090Amit Shah2112/24/2006 21:19
9427306077Pandian919824010090Amit Shah2312/25/2006 8:51
919824010090Amit Shah9427306077Pandian1812/25/2006 14:36
919824010090Amit Shah9427306077Pandian4212/25/2006 21:00
9427306077Pandian919824010090Amit Shah312/26/2006 18:31
9427306077Pandian919824010090Amit Shah17812/26/2006 19:17
919824010090Amit Shah9427306077Pandian7912/27/2006 12:50
9427306077Pandian919427306014Parag4812/30/2006 14:14
9427306077Pandian919824010090Amit Shah4712/30/2006 19:08
9427306077Pandian919824010090Amit Shah10112/30/2006 19:23
9427306077Pandian919824010090Amit Shah1912/31/2006 12:47
9427306077Pandian919824010090Amit Shah2412/31/2006 12:55
919824010090Amit Shah9427306077Pandian412/31/2006 13:40


  1. Confidence Vs Arrogance

    Both , Sheila Dikshit ( Congress ) and Vijay Goel ( BJP ) , are loudly proclaiming that their party will win the forthcoming Delhi Assembly Elections , with a thumping majority

    Even Arvind Kejriwal ( Aam Aadmi Party ) is saying the same

    That is understandable , considering that the Commanders must enthuse their cadres

    Such confidence on their part is a pre-requisite for winning

    But what happens when Sheila Dikshit says ,

    “ Aam Aadmi Party ? Who are they ? Nobody !
    They don’t scare us . They are insignificant .
    What is their agenda ? What is their record ?
    People of Delhi will ignore them ! “

    Now , that is bravado

    People of Delhi !

    For over a decade , you have suffered this insult

    4th December is your time to teach a lesson to the arrogant rulers of Delhi

    By voting / electing , at least 40 AAP candidates

    Only you can give yourself a break !

    • hemen parekh ( 12 Oct 2013 )

  2. Here is another curious fact:

    Parag Shah, in his Linked In profile, also claims that he is the PA to Home Minister of India at Minister’s of Home Affairs / Grih Mantralya! Is he a fraud and imposter? Or, has he added the latest qualification just to confuse readers here and elsewhere? Please visit the following link:

    in.linkedin dot com/in/paragjshah67

  3. What a strange statement by Dr Mukul Sinha? Is it due to the absence of DIRECT EVIDENCE that Modi was not prosecuted since say March 2002.? There was solid evidence even bigger than the Himalayas and vaster than the biggest ocean of Earth. But India’s tragedy was that the INDIAN JUDICIARY from top to bottom blind folded their own eyes for reasons known to the enlightened citizens of India. If one single POLICE OFFICER , with a bold spine, was available in Gujarat in 2002, LK Advani wouldn’t have reason now to weep and shed rain like tears non-stop for the past 6 months. Even RSS and BJP needn’t have entertained the dreadful dream of liquidation in the near future. Parliamentarians need not …….. !!!

  4. Arvind is the way to go against Congress.. BJP cant even talk about her corruption.. They are just cunning shrewd politicians from same lineage..( Refer Vijay Goel crocodile tears on electricity bills). They just copy AAP.. AAP says electricity.. Vijay goel comes behind… AAP says corruption.. they too seem to remember… AAP says use autos… BJP copies … AAP says make manifestos with public involvement.. BJP apes.. AAP says JAN lokpal till 29th.. BJP says.. oh yes.. but dont know the date.. AAP says clean funds.. BJP is no where in the picture.. oh we find them.. where.. in congress lap..

  5. Any lesser person would have been thrown behind the bars on the basis of even less incriminating evidence than this but unfortunately the same rule is not applied to people in high places.The CBI too seem to show a reluctance to go hard on those who are in power or are likely to come to power.

Comments are closed.